Top 14 Countries With The Best Judicial System In The World: The judicial arm of a government is the arm concerned with the interpretation of laws, agreements, treaties, policies and legal frameworks. This arm of government also exercises checks on the other arms- legislative and executive. There are different factors usually responsible for the effectiveness of a judicial system. Some of these factors include respect for the rule of law, timeframe for the resolution of disputes, the manner of judicial interpretations, the availability of judicial officers, among others.
There have been debates from time to time on which countries have the best judicial system in the world. This article gives an answer to this question. The top areas of strengths for all of the countries on this list will be briefly highlighted in the article.
Recommended: Countries with the strongest police force in the world
Criteria for Effectiveness of Judicial Systems
In reaching a conclusion on the top 10 countries with the best judicial systems in the world, the following factors were considered:
a. Accountability: This article considers how the government as well as principal state actors are made to be accountable under the laws in place.
b. Just Laws: For a country to be said to have an effective judicial system, the laws which the judges are called upon to breathe life into must be just and fair in all respect. These laws must be clear and publicized within the state. Such laws must also be of such nature as to protect the core rights of citizens.
c. Open Government: The government of these countries must be one put in power by the majority of the people. The people making up the government and the judiciary must be people of good standing in the society and who have the skill-set and will power to do the job. The government must be fair, accessible and largely efficient.
Also see: Major limitations to the principle of rule of law
d. Accessible Impartial Dispute Resolution Mechanisms: These countries must have in place the right tools to ensure that justice is accessible to every citizen and justice is not just done, but is manifestly seen to have been done even by the common man.
e. Timeframe for Dispute Resolution: There is a widely believed saying that justice delayed is justice denied. It is not sufficient that justice will be served at the end of the judicial process, but there must be steps put in place to ensure that justice is attained within the shortest possible time.
Recommended: Doctrine of covering the field explained
Top 14 Judicial System in the World 2024
The following judicial systems can be regarded as the best in the world. The countries below are taken upon a due consideration of different continents and the judicial systems available in each of these.
1. Denmark: This is a country in the Scandinavian region in Europe. It has its capital at Copenhagen and Danish is the official language. It is scarcely populated country with a population of about 6 million people. The country is placed at the first position in the world considering its very effective judicial system . The country is considered to have a very open government, with respect for the rule of law, and strict regulatory enforcements in place. This country is considered one of the safest places to live on earth and their effective judicial system which has resulted in a great reduction in crimes and conflicts is also a reason for this.
The country has in place over 2 dozens county general courts, and specialized courts for areas such as maritime disputes and commercial disputes. The judges in these courts are specially trained and qualified in these areas. The country has a special court of indictment and revision, which hears cases of disciplinary sanctions against erring judges and judicial officers. There are elaborate rules on re-opening criminal cases in instances where foul play is suspected.
2. Norway: Norway is country in Europe with Oslo as its capital city. The country has one of the best judicial rating in the world presently. It has a very open judicial system and the government’s powers are under constant checks. The country has one of the most effective regulatory enforcements.
There are no civil unrests, almost no crimes and complete absence in violence in the resolution of disputes. Judicial powers are constantly under strong scrutiny to avoid abuse and undue use.
Also see: How to become a successful business entrepreneur
3. Finland: This is a Northern European country which shares borders with Sweeden, Norway and Russia. Helsinki is the capital city of Finland. The country has a population of about 6 million inhabitants.
The country judicial system is made up of a Supreme Court, Six Courts of Appeal and about 27 District Courts. The country is considered to be one of the most secured places in the world to live with almost zero abuse of government powers. The country has strong implementation policies for laws and policies in place.
4. Sweden: This is a Scandinavian country in Europe. Its capital city is Stockholm and the country has a population of about 11 million people. The judicial system of Sweden is made up of two types of courts, the administrative courts and special courts.
This country is one of the safest places to live in the world with almost a total eclipse of corruption. It was rated by the World Justice Project as a country with one of the most advanced and effective judicial systems in the world as at 2020.
Recommended: Advantages and Disadvantages of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
5. Netherlands: This is a country which is situated in the Northwestern part of Europe, with Amsterdam as its capital. It has a population of about 18 million people.
This country has been ranked to be have one of the most developed legal framework in the world. There is easy access to the courts with less cost and a relatively short period of time is used for the judicial determination of disputes in courts.
6. Germany: This is another country in Europe with its capital at Berlin. It is one of the countries with an effective judicial system in place and a booming population. It has a population of about 84million people.
The German legal system is a civil law system most based on very comprehensive statutes. In recent ratings done in recent years, Germany has constantly dominated in the area of regulatory enforcement and a strong criminal justice system.
Also see: Characteristics of the fundamental human rights of Citizens
7. New Zealand: This country is located in Australia, with Wellington as its capital. This is one country outside Europe that is highly regarded as a country with an advanced judicial system.
There are four levels of courts in this country, at the lowest level we have the District Court and High Courts. Appeals move from these courts to the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court. This country has one of the most sophisticated policy implementation mechanism in the world, with a high regard for the rule of law.
8. Austria: The Republic of Austria is a central European country with its capital at Vienna. The country has a population of about 9 million people.
The country is highly reputed for having advanced and up-to-date set of laws, and a hitch-free judicial process. Matters are usually fast-tracked to ensure that a fair decision is reached within the shortest possible time, while at the same time, ensuring that justice is not compromised.
Also see: Most corrupt countries in Africa 2021
9. Canada: This is another country outside Europe in this list. It is a North America country with its capital at Ottawa. The country has a population of about 39 million people. This country has a strong reputation of quick and easy implementation policies in place.
It embraces the use of technology in dispute resolution and adopts mechanisms that ensure that disputes are amicably settled within the shortest possible time. The World Justice Project rates Canada to be the most advanced country with respect to Rule of Law consideration in North America.
10. Estonia: This is a North European country which has its capital at Tallinn. The country has a population of under a million. This country is highly rated for its adoption of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms such as negotiation, arbitration and mediation in the settlement of disputes. The government is under strict check to avoid abuse of its powers.
Recommended: Religious views on smoking
11. United Kingdom: The judiciary in the UK is powerful and incorruptible, and it is comprised of senior lawyers with extensive expertise. It is architecturally and practically separate from the legislative and the executive branch. By doing this, fair and dependable dispute resolution is ensured. The judiciary, one of the three arms of the British government, collaborates with the executive and legislative departments to uphold the law.
The judiciary’s responsibility is to guarantee that laws are correctly applied. This is achieved by first interpreting the legislation and then applying it. Judicial review is a crucial function of the UK judiciary. A public body, like an agency of government or municipal authority, may make a decision or take an action that is subject to judicial review. They can reverse the decision if it was done improperly, the correct procedure wasn’t followed, or it was made for unreasonable reasons.
12. Luxembourg: Located in northwest Europe, Luxembourg is a landlocked nation. It is one of the tiniest countries in the world and is bordered by Belgium on the west and north, France on the south, and Germany on the northeast and east. In its lengthy history, Luxembourg has been ruled by a variety of nations and royal families, but from the 10th century, it has maintained its independence as a distinct political entity, if not always fully.
Despite its tiny size, Luxembourg has rules to be followed and a civil law court system to uphold. Luxembourg has one of the best judicial systems in the world. In Luxembourg, the judiciary is fully separate from other parts of government. The Constitution and the statutes controlling and regulating the structure of the judiciary serve as guarantees of its independence. Judges must maintain professional privacy and remain impartial.
Recommended: Most Popular Fruits In The World: Top 9 Most Consumed
14. Australia: The Southern Hemisphere’s Australia, the world’s smallest continent and one of its largest nations, is situated between the Pacific and Indian oceans. Australia has one of the best legal systems in the world. One of the most advanced legal systems in the entire globe, according to rankings. In Australia, the government, the parliament, and the judiciary all have some legislative authority. This is referred to as the doctrine of the separation of powers and is a fundamental component of the Australian form of government.
The judiciary is separate from the other branches of government under the Australian Constitution. According to the idea of the separation of powers, judges make their own decisions about how to interpret and apply the law without being influenced by either the legislature or the government. The tenure and compensation protections provided by the constitution help to ensure judicial independence.
15. Ireland: Another nation with a strong legal system is Ireland. According to Ireland’s Constitution, judges nominated by the President on the recommendation of the Government are responsible for administering justice in courts created by law; all judges are guaranteed complete independence in the execution of their judicial duties.
The administration of justice, upholding law and order, preventing crime, dealing with criminals, and monitoring prison operations are all responsibilities of the several agencies that make up Northern Ireland’s justice system. The Irish court system operates in what is known as “common law.” Generally speaking, the criminal and civil departments of the Irish legal system each have their specialized courts.
Recommended: Donoghue v Stevenson – Facts, issues and decision
Conclusion
A quick look at the countries above show that they are mostly European countries. This is not surprising considering the level of efficiency that the judicial system in that region brings.
Respect for rule of law, checks of governmental powers, quick resolution of disputes, and implementation of decisions reached by the court are mostly present in these European countries. Conscious efforts must be taken to improve these indices by countries that do not come in this list.
Edeh Samuel Chukwuemeka, ACMC, is a lawyer and a certified mediator/conciliator in Nigeria. He is also a developer with knowledge in various programming languages. Samuel is determined to leverage his skills in technology, SEO, and legal practice to revolutionize the legal profession worldwide by creating web and mobile applications that simplify legal research. Sam is also passionate about educating and providing valuable information to people.